Half Baked Newsletter October 6th.jpg

The Idea:

In August 2019, James Hawkins and Tim Glaser quit their jobs and put their last $8K of salary into a business bank account. James, a Cambridge economics grad and former VP of Sales at an enterprise software company, booked two meetings a day with heads of sales. Tim, who'd run R&D, built whatever James was pitching. Then they watched it die.

A sales territory tool: 15 sales leaders agreed to try it, and one clicked the sign-up link. A predictive CRM: one customer at $20 a month, who never paid the invoice. A 1:1 meeting tool nobody opened. A technical debt tracker that got them into Y Combinator's W20 batch with 600 users, then stalled when nobody would pay. An engineering retention tool that lasted five days.

Five pivots in six months. But one frustration had followed them through every failure. Each time they wanted to understand how people used their products, they had to ship all their user data off to a third-party analytics tool. So they built the thing they wished existed: product analytics developers could host themselves, open source from day one.

They wrote the first line of code on January 23, 2020.

This was the beginning of PostHog.

The Execution:

The lesson? PostHog's hardest pivot was the one with the most traction: a technical debt tool with 600 users and a YC badge. Most founders would have tweaked it, scraped together a small seed and spent years propping it up. James and Tim walked away because they didn't believe in it, and the winning idea came from a frustration they'd felt across all five failures. Traction you don't believe in is just a slower way to fail.